In a unattributed order, the U.S. Supreme Court cleared the way for Texas to use a newly configured congressional map that could add up to five new conservative-tilting districts. The six-to-three order, issued on Thursday, approves a request by the state to lift a lower court's block that had rejected the new map in November.
Court's Rationale
The federal judge improperly inserted itself into an ongoing primary campaign, creating much confusion and disrupting the fine equilibrium in elections, the justices wrote in detailing its decision.
The federal court had previously found that Texas had likely classified voters according to their race – a practice known as illegal race-based districting – when it enacted the boundaries. It had instructed the state to employ the boundaries established after the last decennial survey for the upcoming election.
Sharp Dissent
Through a sharply worded dissent, Justice Elena Kagan objected to the majority's action. She contended that it undermined the work of the district court, noting that its opinion was actually authored by a judge nominated by former President Donald Trump.
Our position is above the district court, but our capability is not greater for resolving such fact-driven issues, Kagan wrote in a dissent co-signed by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson.
She continued, The majority's order solidifies that Texas's redistricting plan, with all its increased favoritism, will dictate next year's elections. And it ensures that many Texas residents, without justification, will be placed in electoral districts based on their race. And that result, as this court has stated year in and year out, is a breach of the law of the land.
National Map-Drawing Struggle
This decision comes amid a countrywide fight over the redrawing of electoral maps. Texas is a crucial component in campaigns to transform the U.S. House map to bolster a slim Republican majority. Usually, redistricting occurs after a new decade's census. Yet the move by Texas Republicans to proceed with a brazen off-cycle redistricting earlier in the summer set off a chain reaction among other states.
Republicans in including North Carolina and Missouri have also enacted new maps that might create several additional GOP-friendly seats. Democratic lawmakers, for their part, have countered with revised boundaries in states like California and Virginia, which could offset those projected gains.
Partisan Responses
The Texas top lawyer hailed the supreme court ruling. In a statement, he said the order upheld Texas's prerogative to draw a map that guarantees representation aligned with the GOP. Our state is leading the charge to reclaim the nation, one district and one state at a time, he added.
On the other hand, opposition party officials lamented the decision. It's incredibly disappointing that the Court has rubber stamped a map enacted by Texas Republicans which, simply put, is an extreme, racially gerrymandered map, said the head of a major Democratic campaign committee.
Another top House leader stated the court had another time shredded its standing by rubber-stamping a discriminatory map. This decision from the Court's far-right bloc proves extremists are willing to rig elections. The Texas map is a discriminatory power grab targeting Black and Latino voters, he added.